Essential to my Modern Datacenter Lab: Azure Site 2 Site VPN with a DELL SonicWALL Firewall

If you’re a serious operator in the part of IT that is considered the tip of the spear, i.e. you’re the one getting things done, you need a lab. I have had one (well I upgraded it a couple of times) for a long time. When you’re dealing with cloud as an IT Pro, mostly Microsoft Azure in my case, that need has not changed. It enables you gain the knowledge and insights that you can only acquire by experimenting and hands on work, there is no substitute. Sometimes people ask me how I learn. A lab and lots of hands on experimenting is a major component of my self education and training. I put in a lot of time and some money, yes.

Perhaps you have a lab at work, perhaps not, but you do need one. A lab is a highly valuable investment in education for both your employers and yourself. It takes a lot of time, effort and it cost a bit of money. The benefits however are huge and I encourage any employer who has IT staff to sponsor this at the ROI is huge for a relative small TCO.

I love the fact that in a lab you have (and want) complete control over the entire stack so you experiment at will and learn about the solutions you build end to end. You do need to deal with it all but that’s all good, you learn even more, even when at times it’s tough going. Note that a home lab, even with the associated costs, has the added benefit of still being available to you even if you move between employers or between clients.

You can set up a site to site VPN using Windows Server 2012 R2 RRAS (see Site-to-Site VPN in Azure Virtual Network using Windows Server 2012 Routing and Remote Access Service (RRAS) that works. But for for long term lab work and real life implementations you’ll be using other devices. In the SOHO lab I run everything virtualized & I need internet access for other uses cases than the on premises lab. I also like to minimize the  hosts/VMs/appliances I need to have running to save on electricity costs. For enterprise grade solutions you leverage solutions form CISCO, JUNIPER, CheckPoint etc. There is no need for “enterprise grade” solutions in a SOHO or small branch office environment.Those are out of budget & overkill, so I needed something else. There are some options out there but I’m using a DELL SonicWALL NSA 220. This is a quality product for one and I could get my hands on one in a very budget friendly manner. UTMs & the like are not exactly cheap, even without all the subscription, but they don’t exactly cater to the home user normally. You can go higher or lower but I would not go below a TZ-205 (Wireless) which is great value for money and more than up for the task of providing you with the capabilities you need in a home lab.

SonicWALL NSA 220 Wireless-N Appliance

I consider this minimum level as I want 1Gbps (no I do not buy 100Mbps equipment in 2015) and I want wireless to make sure I don’t need to have too many hardware devices in the lab. As said, the benefit over the RRAS solution are that it serves other purposes (UTM) and it can remain running cheaply so you can connect to the lab remotely to fire up your hosts and VMs which you normally power down to safe power.

Microsoft only dynamic routing with a limited number of vendors/devices but that doesn’t mean all others are off limits. You can use them but you’ll have to research the configurations that work instead of downloading the configuration manual or templates from the Microsoft web site, which is still very useful to look at an example configuration, even if it’s another product than you use.

Getting it to work is a multistep proccess:

    1. Set up your Azure virtual network.
    2. Configure your S2S VPN on the SonicWall
    3. Test connectivity between a on premises VM and one in the cloud
    4. Build out your hybrid or public cloud

Here’s a reference to get you started Tutorial: Create a Cross-Premises Virtual Network for Site-to-Site Connectivity I will be sharing my setup for the SonicWall in a later blog post so you can use it as a reference. For now, here’s a schematic overview of my home lab setup to Azure (the IP addresses are fakes). At home I use VDSL and it’s a dynamic IP address so every now and then I need to deal with it changing. I’d love to have a couple of static IP address to play with but that’s not within my budget. I wrote a little Azure scheduled run book that takes care of updating the dynamic IP address in my Azure site-to-site VPN setup. It’s also published on the TechNet Gallery


You can build this with WIndows RRAS, any UTM, Firewall etc … device that is a bit more capable than a consumer grade (wireless) router. The nice things is that I’ve had multiple subnets on premises and the 10 tunnels in a standard Azure  site-to-site VPN accommodate that nicely. The subnets I don’t want to see in a tunnel to azure I just leave out of the configuration.

Tip to save money in your Azure lab for newbies, shut down everything you can when your done. Automate it with PowerShell. I just make sure my hybrid infra is online & the VPN active enough to make sure we don’t run into out of sync issues with AD etc.

Azure Automation Scheduled Runbook PowerShell Script to automatically update site-to-site VPN Local Network VPN Gateway Address with dynamic public IP

You can download the script at the end of the article. When you’re connecting a home (or perhaps even an office) lab to Azure with a site-2-site VPN you’ll probably have to deal with the fact that you have a dynamic IP assigned by your ISP. This means unless you update the VPN Gateway Address of your Azure local network in some automated way, your connection is down very often and you’re faced with this this in Azure …


which on my DELL SonicWALL NSA 220 that looks like this …


A fellow MVP of mine (Christopher Keyaert) has written a PowerShell script that a few years back that updated the VPN gateway address of your Azure local network via a scheduled task inside of his Windows RRAS VM. Any VM, either in Azure or in your lab will do. Good stuff! If you need inspiration for a script  you have a link. But, I never liked the fact that keeping my Azure site-to-site VPN up and running was tied to a VM being on line in Azure or in my lab, which is also why I switched to a SonicWALL device. Since we have Azure Automation runbooks at our disposal I decided to automate the updating of the VPN gateway address to the dynamic IP address of my ISP using a runbook.

Finding out your dynamic IP address from anywhere in the world

For this to work you need a way to find out what your currently assigned dynamic IP is. For that I subscribe to a free service providing dynamic DNS updates. I use That means that by looking up the FQDN is find can out my current dynamic IP address form where ever I have internet access. As my SonicWALL supports dynamic DNS services providers I can configure it there, no need for an update client running in a VM or so.


The runbook to update the VPN Gateway Address of your Azure local network

I will not deal with how to set up Azure Automation, just follow this link. I will share a little hurdle I needed to take. At least for me it was a hurdle. That hurdle was that the Set-AzureVNetConfig cmdlet which we need has a mandatory parameter -ConfigurationPath which reads the configuration to set from an XML file (see Azure Virtual Network Configuration Schema).

You cannot just use a file path in an Azure runbook to dump a file on c:\temp  for example. Using an Azure file share seems overly complicated for this job. After pinging some fellow MVPs at Inovativ Belgium who are deep into Azure automation on a daily basis, Stijn Callebaut gave me the tip to use [System.IO.Path]::GetTempFileName() and that got my script working. Thank you Stijn Winking smile!

So I now have a scheduled runbook that automatically updates my to the dynamic IP address my ISP renews every so often without needing to have a script running scheduled inside a VM. I don’t always need a VM running but I do need that VPN to be there for other use cases. This is as elegant of a solution that I could come up with.

I test the script before publishing & scheduling it by setting the VPN Gateway Address of my Azure local network to a wrong IP address in order to see whether the runbook changes it to the current one it got from my dynamic IP. As you can see it was successful.


Now publish it and have it run x times a day … depending on how aggressive your ISP renews your IP address and how long your lab can sustain the Azure site-to-site VPN to be down. I do it hourly. Not a production ready solution, but neither is a dynamic IP and this is just my home lab!


Now my VPN looks happy most of the time automatically



Download the runbook  here (zipped PowerShell script)

DELL SonicWALL Site-to-Site VPN Options With Azure Networking

The DELL SonicWALL product range supports both policy based and route based VPN configurations. Specifically for Azure they have a configuration guide out there that will help you configure either.

Technically, networking people prefer to use route based configuration. It’s more flexible to maintain in the long run. As life is not perfect and we do not control the universe, policy based is also used a lot. SonicWALL used to be on the supported list for both a Static and Dynamically route Azure VPN connections. According to this thread it was taken off because some people had reliability issues with performance. I hope this gets fixed soon in a firmware release. Having that support is good for DELL as a lot of people watch that list to consider what they buy and there are not to many vendors on it in the more budget friendly range as it is. The reference in that thread to DELL stating that Route-Based VPN using Tunnel Interface is not supported for third party devices, is true but a bit silly as that’s a blanket statement in the VPN industry where there is a non written rule that you use route based when the devices are of the same brand and you control both points. But when that isn’t the case, you go a policy based VPN, even if that’s less flexible.

My advise is that you should test what works for you, make your choice and accept the consequences. In the end it determines only who’s going to have to fix the problem when it goes wrong. I’m also calling on DELL to sort this out fast & good.

A lot of people get confused when starting out with VPNs. Add Azure into the equation, where we also get confused whilst climbing the learning curve, and things get mixed up. So here a small recap of the state of Azure VPN options:

  • There are two to create a Site-to-Site VPN VPN between an Azure virtual network (and all the subnets it contains) and your on premises network (and the subnets it contains).
    1. Static Routing: this is the one that will work with just about any device that supports policy based VPNs in any reasonable way, which includes a VPN with Windows RRAS.
    2. Dynamic Routing: This one is supported with a lot less vendors, but that doesn’t mean it won’t work. Do your due diligence. This also works with Windows RRAS

Note: Microsoft now has added a a 3rd option to it’s Azure VPN Gateway offerings, the High Performance VPN gateway, for all practical purposes it’s dynamic routing, but a more scalable version. Note that this does NOT support static routing.

The confusion is partially due to Microsoft Azure, network industry and vendor terminology differing from each other. So here’s the translation table for DELL SonicWALL & Azure

Dynamic Routing in Azure Speak is a Route-Based VPN in SonicWALL terminology and is called and is called Tunnel Interface in the policy type settings for a VPN.


Static Routing in Azure Speak is a Policy-Based VPN in SonicWALL terminology and is called Site-To-Site in the “Policy Type” settings for a VPN.


  • You can only use one. So you need to make sure you won’t mix the two on both sites as that won’t work for sure.
  • Only a Pre-Shared Key (PSK) is currently supported for authentication. There is no support yet for certificate based authentication at the time of writing).

Also note that you can have 10 tunnels in a standard Azure site-to-site VPN which should give you enough wiggling room for some interesting scenarios. If not scale up to the high performance Azure site-to site VPN or move to Express Route. In the screenshot below you can see I have 3 tunnels to Azure from my home lab.

I hope this clears out any confusion around that subject!