Transparent Failover & Node Fault Tolerance With SMB 2.2 Tested

Transparent Failover and node fault tolerance with SMB 2.2 in Windows 8 Server is something that caught my attention immediately. The entire effort in infrastructure has been to keep the plumbing as invisible & unnoticed as possible. In some areas we had great success in others not so much. Planned & unplanned down time of file servers has always been an issue as there was always a short or longer outage and any failover meant disconnecting & reconnecting leading to all kinds of end users problems and confusion. To them the network is down. But the same issues exist on the server side with apps depending on files shares or servers like SQL Server that are writing backups to remote share or read data from such a share. Often it needs some kind of human intervention to correct the situation. No not even 3rd party clustered file systems and active-active clustering software could achieve this. The SMB protocol prior to 2.2 did not allow for it.

So when one hears it is a possibility now we want to test this! So we throw some virtual machines on the test cluster and build a file cluster with windows 8 server and we also have a 3rd server to act as a client with SMB 2.2. Open the Failover Cluster Manager right click roles and choose to configure a role.

image

You’ll see the familiar wizard, click next

image

And choose the file server role

image

Give the Client Access Point a name and add an IP address.

image

Add some storage

image

And voila … after the confirmation we’re asked to configure high availability

image

This opens the New Share Wizard

image

…this is all pretty straight forward so I’ll leave out the screenshots but for the most important one where we explicitly uncheck the “Enable continuous availability” as we want to first run a test without it Smile

image

Continue through the wizard & voila you have a clustered file server with a Client Access Point as a single namespace. Please not that you can connect to this using that single name space. No need for \serverABizzShare & \ServerBBizzShare and going fancy with redundant DFS name spaces and the like.

Remember we still need to make this share highly available but let’s do some file copies and fail over the node to see what this looks like without transparent failover. Select the role transparent, right click, choose “Move” and “Select  Node”.

image

Choose an available node and click OK

image

As you can see this looks rather familiar.image

Let’s make that share continuously available. Go to and double click on the share you want to configure.

image

You’ll see a progress dialog whilst information is retrieved …

image

… and then the share properties are presented, most is familiar stuff but we need the bottom one “Settings”. Select the check box to make the share continuously available.

image

Now let’s try that file copy of again whilst failing over the file server role to another node.

image

So there is no loss of data, no need to the client to reconnect, you don’t have to retry but you do have a freeze that lasts for about 20 seconds on my test lab. I hope this will still improve before RTM.

What we learned here is that we can have Transparent (File Share) failover with SMB 2.2 in a virtualized environment and we can give it a “Client Access Point” name like “MyOldFileServer” so that users are not confused or need to learn another UNC path. There are many options to achieve keeping old namespaces around for end user ease of use but this is an extra ace up our sleeve. For now planned (patching, server maintenance) or unplanned (crash) is a 20 second freeze experience right now as the file share fails over. This freeze is probably due to active–passive clustering. For now active-active is not recommended/supported for file sharing in an end user scenario. I think they are “worried” of huge file shares with a zillion meta data updates to sync. But this is supported for apps like hyper-V, SQL Server backups or apps needing file data etc. I’m going to try it next and for user data. Things might change before RTM and with multichannel, RDAM, 10Gbps, NIC teaming in the OS perhaps that active-active scenario might be feasible for user file data? PLEASE? Otherwise here’s another request for “Windows 8 Server R2” Winking smile

The secret sauce is in:

  • SMB 2.2 on both client & server
  • Resume Key
  • SMB 2.2 Witness service which is stet to running when you make an share continuous available.

image

Go watch the sessions from the Build conference to hear more on al this. The work they’ve put in to this  + some of the complexities are quite amazing. http://www.buildwindows.com/Sessions

Things to find out: how to rename a Client Access Point or how to delete it. Adding a new one is easy.

Warning: It’s September 23rd 2011 and the Developer Preview is a little rough around the edges don’t run this on anything you need to get your bills paid yet  Winking smile

5 thoughts on “Transparent Failover & Node Fault Tolerance With SMB 2.2 Tested

  1. Pingback: Active-Active File sharing with SMB 2.2 Scale Out in Windows 8Rocks | Working Hard In IT

  2. Hi,
    Thank you for your post, it was very useful to read.
    I’m starting to test the feature myself as well. What I was wondering; you mentioned that you need to have SMB 2.2 both on client and server – so did you used Server 8 as an client, since Windows 7 does not have support for SMB 2.2 yet?

    Best regards,
    Thinh

    • Hello Thinh,

      Yes that is correct. I used a 3rd server as a client. I did throw the “wish” out there to MSFT to provide SMB 2.2 support in Windows 7 with a service pack but whether that will ever happen remains to be seen. I hope we’ll get more infor when they start releasing new info on Windows 8. This should be around the time they release the first beta, end of 2011, early 2012.

      Thx for reading!

      • Thx for your response. My best guess is that it will officially become available with Windows 8 for consumers somewhere mid-2012.

        One way to provide SMB 2.2 to users would be to setup Remote Desktop on Server 8, if one really can’t wait ;-D

        Best regards,
        Thinh

  3. Pingback: SMB 3, ODX, Windows Server 2012 R2 & Windows 8.1 perform magic in file sharing for both corporate & branch offices | Working Hard In IT

Leave a Reply